This website and the documents it makes are not a substitute for the advice of an attorney.
Guides and research: how towing works in El Paso
Plain-language guides for people who were towed, and the audits, reports and court rulings behind them. Each summary is ours; follow the link to read the original.
Report · U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division · · Covers: El Paso
The federal case alleging that at least 176 servicemembers' vehicles were auctioned from the City's storage facility without court orders, and the 2025 settlements with the City and two contractors.
Why it matters: Shows the extra protection servicemembers have before a towed car can be sold.
EPPD Municipal Vehicle Storage Facility Audit (A2020-02)
Audit · City of El Paso Internal Audit Office · · Covers: El Paso
Tested whether the police department and the storage-lot contractor followed the 2019 contract. It found early auction sales, no servicemember check before sales, an outdated manual and an overfull hold lot.
Why it matters: The City's own warning, three years before the federal lawsuit, that servicemembers' cars were not being checked before sale.
Study · El Paso Police Department · · Covers: Texas and nearby cities
Gives the city's fee history, compares Texas and regional cities (including Las Cruces and Albuquerque), and summarizes TDLR's 2012 statewide towing-fee study, which it said did not reflect the El Paso region well.
Why it matters: A rare official comparison of tow limits across Texas cities.
Court rulings about towing in El Paso. A case decides the dispute in front of the court; whether it applies to a tow depends on the facts.
City of Columbus v. Ours Garage & Wrecker Service, Inc., 536 U.S. 424 (). The U.S. Supreme Court held that states may let cities make safety rules for tow trucks despite federal limits on regulating motor carriers' prices, routes and services.
United States v. City of El Paso, et al., No. 3:23-cv-00044 (W.D. Tex.) (). Servicemembers Civil Relief Act case over servicemembers' vehicles auctioned from the City's storage facility without court orders; resolved by settlements with the City and both contractors in 2025.